Laylatul-Qadr -A Night of Blessings, or A Tradition Built on Guesswork?
What if the most anticipated night in the Muslim calendar was never meant to be a calendar night at all?
Every year during the month of Ramadhan, Muslims around the world eagerly search for a night called Laylatul-Qadr. It is believed that whoever worships during this night will receive blessings greater than a thousand months.
Mosques remain open until dawn. Worshippers intensify their prayers. Believers wait with hope that perhaps this year they might witness the sacred night.
But a simple question is rarely asked:
What if Surah Al-Qadr was never describing a specific night in the first place?
The Calendar Problem
The date of Laylatul-Qadr is inseparable from the Hijri calendar, specifically the last ten nights of the month of Ramadhan.
This assumption carries a major implication:
that the Lord of the Universe operates according to the Arabic lunar calendar.
Yet the Hijri calendar itself is merely a continuation of the pre-Islamic Arabic calendar, the same system that existed during the period commonly described as Jahiliyyah.
In previous parts of this series, we have shown that the current Hijri calendar no longer reflects the seasonal cycle that originally defined Ramadhan. The word Ramadhan itself refers to intense heat, yet today Muslims observe Ramadhan in every season of the year.
If the calendar itself is flawed, then the question becomes unavoidable:
Can a divinely appointed night truly depend on a human calendar that has drifted away from its original context?
What exactly are we searching for each year?
When is Laylatul-Qadr?
Despite the central importance of this night in Muslim devotion, the actual date remains unknown.
Islamic traditions offer several conflicting possibilities.
Some narrations say the night occurs during the last ten nights of Ramadhan.
Others specify the odd nights within those ten days.
Some traditions suggest the 21st, 23rd, or 25th night.
Others claim it could be the 25th, 27th, or 29th night.
According to one narration, the Prophet had once been shown the date but forgot it after witnessing a quarrel among two individuals.
Volume 3, Book 32, Number 235 : Narrated by Abu Said Al-Khudri - Allah's Apostle used to practice Itikaf (in the mosque) in the middle third of Ramadan and after passing the twenty nights he used to go back to his house on the 21st, and the people who were in Itikaf with him also used to go back to their houses. Once in Ramadan, in which he practiced Itikaf, he established the night prayers at the night in which he used to return home, and then he addressed the people and ordered them whatever Allah wished him to order and said, "I used to practice Itikaf for these ten days (i.e. the middle 113rd but now I intend to stay in Itikaf for the last ten days (of the month); so whoever was in Itikaf with me should stay at his place of seclusion. I have verily been shown (the date of) this Night (of Qadr) but I have forgotten it. So search for it in the odd nights of the last ten days (of this month). I also saw myself (in the dream) prostrating in mud and water." On the night of the 21st, the sky was covered with clouds and it rained, and the rain-water started leaking through the roof of the mosque at the praying place of the Prophet . I saw with my own eyes the Prophet at the completion of the morning prayer leaving with his face covered with mud and water.
Volume 3, Book 32, Number 240 : Narrated by 'Ubada bin As-Samit - The Prophet came out to inform us about the Night of Qadr but two Muslims were quarreling with each other. So, the Prophet said, "I came out to inform you about the Night of Qadr but such-and-such persons were quarreling, so the news about it had been taken away; yet that might be for your own good, so search for it on the 29th, 27th and 25th (of Ramadan).
The general belief of the occurrence of Laylatul-Qadr is within the last ten nights of Ramadhan.
Narrated by 'AishaAllah's Apostle used to practice Itikaf in the last ten nights of Ramadan and used to say, "Look for the Night of Qadr in the last ten nights of the month of Ramadan."
Sahih Bukhari Volume 3, Book 32, Number 237
(also Sahih Muslim 1174)
However, this was narrowed down to the odd numbered nights;
Narrated by 'AishaAllah's Apostle said, "Search for the Night of Qadr in the odd nights of the last ten days of Ramadan."
Sahih Bukhari Volume 3, Book 32, Number 234
According to Ibn Abbas, it could be on the 21st, 23rd or 25th nights.
Narrated by Ibn AbbasThe Prophet said, "Look for the Night of Qadr in the last ten nights of Ramadan ,' on the night when nine or seven or five nights remain out of the last ten nights of Ramadan (i.e. 21, 23, 25, respectively)."
Sahih Bukhari Volume 3, Book 32, Number 238 (also 239)
While 'Ubada bin As-Samit said it was on 25th, 27th and 29th nights.
Narrated by 'Ubada bin As-SamitThe Prophet came out to inform us about the Night of Qadr but two Muslims were quarreling with each other. So, the Prophet said, "I came out to inform you about the Night of Qadr but such-and-such persons were quarreling, so the news about it had been taken away; yet that might be for your own good, so search for it on the 29th, 27th and 25th (of Ramadan).
Sahih Bukhari Volume 3, Book 32, Number 240
This raises an obvious difficulty.
If the exact night is unknown, then believers are left doing the same thing every year:
They search.
They hope.
They guess.
But certainty never arrives.
When certainty disappears, speculation takes its place.
And speculation, repeated often enough, eventually becomes tradition.
Traditional understanding of searching Laylatul Qadr here.
The Scholars’ Explanation
Many scholars argue that the date was intentionally concealed so that believers would strive harder in worship during the final ten nights of Ramadhan.
According to this explanation, uncertainty encourages devotion.
As Ibn Qudamah al-Maqdisi (d. 620 H) writes:
God has concealed this night from the ummah so that they may strive in seeking it and performing worship throughout the month in the hopes of catching it. Similarly, He concealed the hour of special acceptance on Friday so that one would increase in their supplications throughout the day, and He concealed His Greatest Name (ism al-a’dham) amongst His Divine Names and His Pleasure with acts of obedience so that people would strive for them. And He concealed an individual’s lifespan and the Hour [of the Day of Judgment] so that humanity would continuously strive in good deeds, being heedful of them.
Ibn Qudamah,al-Mughni (Dar `Alam al-Kutub), vol. 4, p. 453.
But this reasoning leads to another question.
A Spiritual Lottery?
If the exact night is unknown, then believers are essentially taking chances during the final ten nights.
Is this not similar to a spiritual lottery?
The Quran explicitly condemns games of chance:
2:219. They ask you about [the] intoxicants and [the] games of chance Say, "In both of them (is) a sin great, and (some) benefits for [the] people. But sin of both of them (is) greater than (the) benefit of (the) two." And they ask you what they (should) spend. Say, "The surplus." Thus makes clear Allah to you [the] Verses so that you may ponder,
Yet the belief surrounding Laylatul-Qadr suggests that a person may receive blessings equal to more than eighty years of worship simply by happening to perform rituals on the correct night.
Such an idea introduces a troubling implication.
Could a person neglect righteousness throughout the year, yet hope to secure enormous rewards simply by catching the right night?
More importantly:
For fourteen centuries Muslims have searched for this night.
Yet no one has ever been able to say with certainty:
“I witnessed Laylatul-Qadr.”
Year after year, the search continues.
But tangible evidence never appears.
Faith does not grow from guessing.
Truth does not hide behind uncertainty.
The Quran’s Warning Against Guesswork
The Quran repeatedly warns against following assumptions and speculation.
6:116 And if you obey most of those in the earth they will mislead you from the way of Allah. Not they follow except THE ASSUMPTION (al-zana), and not they do except GUESS (yakhrusūna).
10:36 And not follow most of them except ASSUMPTION (zannan). Indeed, THE ASSUMPTION (al-zana) does not avail against the truth anything. Indeed, Allah (is) All-Knower of what they do.
10:48 Will say those who associate partners with Allah, "If had willed Allah, not we would have associated partners with All and not our forefathers and not we would have forbidden of anything." Likewise denied those who from were before them until they tasted Our wrath. Say, "Is with you of any knowledge then produce it for us? Not you follow except THE ASSUMPTION [al-ẓana], and not you do but GUESS [takhruṣūn]",
10:66 No doubt! Indeed, to Allah belongs whoever is in the heavens and whoever is in the earth. And not follow those who invoke from other than Allah, partners. Not they follow but THE ASSUMPTION (al-zana) and not they but GUESS (yakhrusūna).
53:23. Not they are except names you have named them, you and your forefathers, not has sent down Allah for it any authority. Not they follow except ASSUMPTION [al-ẓana] and what desire their souls. And certainly has come to them from their Lord the guidance.
53:28 And not for them about it any knowledge. Not they follow but THE ASSUMPTION [al-ẓana]. And indeed, THE ASSUMPTION [al-ẓana] does not avail against the truth anything.
49:12 O you who believe! Avoid much of THE ASSUMPTION (al-zani). Indeed, some ASSUMPTION (al-zani) (is) sin. And (do) not spy and (do) not backbite some of you (to) others. Would like one of you to eat (the) flesh (of) his brother, dead? Nay, you would hate it. And fear Allah; indeed, Allah (is) Oft-Returning, Most Merciful.
67:5 And certainly we have adorned the heavens, the worlds with lamps and we have made it FUTILE GUESSES [rujūman] for the evil ones and prepared for them sufferings of the blaze
In each of these verses, the Quran criticizes those who abandon certainty and instead follow conjecture.
Yet the entire pursuit of Laylatul-Qadr depends on guessing.
Believers are encouraged to perform rituals in the hope that one of those nights might be the right one.
But the Quran never teaches salvation through speculation.
Thus we find ourselves faced with a religious belief that:
- contradicts the Quranic condemnation of speculation
- depends on an unreliable calendar
- and produces no observable result
How much further must distortion go?
Are we really to believe that God plays dice with human destiny?
What About Accountability?
The Quran consistently teaches that human beings are rewarded according to their actions.
Surah An-Najm states:
53:38 — No bearer of burdens shall carry the burden of another.
53:39 — And that the human being will have only what he strives for.
53:40 — And his effort will be seen.
53:41 — Then he will be fully rewarded for it.
Likewise:
14:51 — That Allah may repay every soul for what it has earned.
And:
4:85 — Whoever supports a good cause will share in its benefit.
Every individual earns according to their deeds.
2:134 This (was) a community (which) has passed away, for it what it earned and for you what you have earned. And not you will be asked about what they used to do.
Also repeated in 2:141
The Quran does not contradict itself.
There are no shortcuts.
There is no spiritual windfall.
There is no “deal of the century.”
So if Surah Al-Qadr is not describing a mystical night within the Arabic calendar, then what does it truly mean?
Perhaps the real question is not “When is Laylatul-Qadr?”
But rather:
“What is Al-Qadr?”
In the following post, we examine Surah Al-Qadr (97:1-5) carefully to uncover its deeper message.
Comments
Post a Comment